The Central Avenue resident said he parked his Audi Q5 in the driveway with the key fob still inside Saturday night, Lt. Frank Riggo said.
His wife later pulled her car in behind it, he said.
When the owner woke up the next morning, the Audi was gone.
Riggio reminded residents and merchants to lock their cars and never leave the key fobs or valuables inside.
Click here to follow Daily Voice West Milford and receive free news updates.